Came in with a degree of caution given the hype around this place, but absolutely loved Prince Street Pizza when I tried it last week. The sauce is legitimately amazing and so unique, and I actually liked the thickness and square shape despite normally being meh on Sicilian style pizza. Would highly highly recommend to anyone visiting NY and looking for great pizza

As you bite into the pizza the first thing that you will notice is the perfectly crispy crust followed by the soft and airy dough. The pepperoni here is SO good. It's thick, meaty, and smoky with a hint of spice. I wish I got to try the spicy vodka but will hopefully get a chance next time I am there! Definitely give it a try if you love pepperoni!

Prince St. Pizza is an absolute gem! The highlight of my visit was undoubtedly the Spicy Vodka Pizza. Each bite was an explosion of flavor, with the perfect blend of creamy, tangy vodka sauce and just the right amount of heat. The crust was crispy on the outside and wonderfully chewy inside, providing the perfect base for this culinary masterpiece. The Spicy Pepperoni Pizza was a close second. The pepperoni slices were generously layered, each bite offering a satisfying crunch and a spicy kick that balanced beautifully with the rich, gooey cheese. While the Four Cheese Pizza was good, it didn't quite stand up to the other two in terms of flavor. If I had to choose, I'd definitely go for the Spicy Vodka or Spicy Pepperoni. Prince St. Pizza has set the bar high for delicious, flavorful pizza, and I can't wait to return for more!

This is probably one of the best pizza slices I've ever had. After being dragged here by a friend from the Bronx, waiting a half an hour in line and eating over a trash can, I can honestly say, it was all worth it. The sauce was sooooo flavorful. I got the spicy pepperoni. I wish I got 2. But for $7 per slice I didn't want to be stuck in case I didn't like it. This place is tiny and there is very little seating or eating area. But I can't wait to go back and have another slice. I think what I loved most was the flavor of the sauce and the dough. It wasn't too doughy or over cooked. Every element of the pizza had flavor. As busy as they were, the staff was quite nice. I'm rating this restaurant 4.5 stars but I always round up. Everyone should check this place out if they are in New York.

Finally got the chance to see what all the hype was about and all I can say is...the rumors ARE true. Prince street pizza is fireeee. I got the naughty slice with pepperoni, vodka sauce and hot honey. It was amazing, the pizza was fluffy yet crispy, salty yet sweet. I can see why this place always has a line. It's amazing! My only regret is not asking if one of those prince street pizza SnapBack hats were for sale.

Probably the best deep dish pizza in NYC! Went there a few months ago with high expectations and was not disappointed. The 20 minute wait went by quickly and the service was great. Quick order, 7-8 minute wait and we got the best slices. The shop looks very nice and with all the pictures on the walls you can browse around a lot so the wait goes by quickly. 10/10 - would recommend!

I've been here a few times and my experience has been about the same: -15 min wait time from line to pizza in hand (get your cheese and pepper from the shakers on the side standing counters) -my favorite was the spicy vodka (apparently it's also very popular and it's always fresh). Spicy pepperoni was also another fav by most others. -slices are about $6-7 each. I got 3 slices for $26.46 including tip -no bathroom -pick up napkins when you pay -say thank you Prince St Pizza is different from the others I've tried because the red tomato sauce has a rich and sweet taste to it. A few chairs outside but you just take it to go and eat by the counter inside or you stand out on the street. Tip: make sure you ask if the person in front of you is in line - there's a lot of tourists so sometimes they like just standing in places they don't realize is actually a line.

Mangiare! No trip to Manhattan can be complete without a pilgrimage to - Prince Street Pizza! I was lucky to get here when I did because my wait time after I ordered my slices was short - less than 7mins. I sat down outside & noticed the line up was now a block long. The walls inside PSP are covered with pix of all the greats that have come through for a slice. I absolutely enjoyed my slices - chewy, gooey cheese pulls & dripping oil all over my hands! The sauce on this pizza is purely ahhhhhhh mazing! Don't come to eat here wearing a suit! I surprised myself at how fast I chomped down on all 3 slices = gone in a flash. Don't fool yourself - you're hungry, go ahead order 3 slices or you'll be back in line for 30mins! Located Downtown aka Lower Manhattan, there's lots to do & see around here in the NoHo neighbourhood, so plan accordingly. Do not leave NYC without first trying NYC pizza! Capisce!?!